by Dan Mayer
If you tell me your show prominently features a hand puppet, you’ve immediately piqued my interest (see my review of ACT’s Fuddy Meers last year). A bit of silliness doesn’t mean a show can’t also be smart and emotionally resonant, and Creative Action Unlimited‘s latest original production Counter Culture combines big belly laughs with sharp social commentary.
Connie (Anna Dempf) is the wife of a conservative politician, and she hosts a live stream from her kitchen counter where she does cooking tutorials, shares homemaking tips, and espouses the virtues of her faith and the “trad-wife” lifestyle. The show is co-hosted by her adorable cat puppet sidekick Cinnamon, but when controversy starts brewing in the chat, Cin (Shae Fitzgerald) starts taking a more active role in proceedings. Things start getting surreal, and once all the secrets have come to light, it’s clear Connie will never be the same.
What starts as a one-woman show for Dempf soon becomes a two-hander with Fitzgerald, and while Dempf is wonderful on her own as the dutiful housewife playing to the camera, the show is vastly elevated once she and Fitzgerald are playing off of one another. The comedy bounces between broad slapstick and incisive satire, with the action frequently moving and utilizing the entire set, so when the emotional weight of the situation finally comes to light, it’s enough of a gut punch to bring the audience to tears.
Every aspect of this production is astounding. Both the writing and direction by KD McTeigue and Michael Kennedy are some of the best I’ve seen in recent memory. The script does a terrific job making Connie likable and sympathetic, while also making it abundantly clear why the rhetoric she shares with her audience is harmful, especially to her. The set by Michael A. Lake is spacious and remarkably detailed for the size of the production, and the actors make great use of the space and props (Kat Fronheiser and Michael Kennedy) throughout the performance. Fitzgerald in particular frequently toys with various items on the table in a very cat-like manner.
The lighting and sound design (M Pomazal-Flanders and Andrew Deitch respectively) are perfectly in sync. The computer voice reading out “superchats” from the live stream’s audience is effectively a third character in the show, with comedic and dramatic timing that excellently complement the actors’ performances.
Even the costumes by Shae Fitzgerald, Cameryn Coetzee, and Michael Kennedy are terrific. Connie’s dress and apron have an appropriately quaint home-made look. Cinnamon’s outfit is nearly identical but the color and pattern are notably the reverse of Connie’s, possibly hinting at Cin’s true nature.
In short, Counter Culture achieves everything that good community theater should strive for. It’s a harmonious collaboration of talented people, bringing to life a story that is unique, powerful, and relevant to our current social climate. It’s funny, heart-breaking, thought-provoking, and it has a cute cat puppet. It even has a pun in the title. What more could you possibly ask for?
Creative Action Unlimited presents Counter Culture, written and directed by KD McTeigue and Michael Kennedy, runs from Nov. 13th – 21st, at The Arts Center of the Capital Region, 265 River Street in Troy, NY. Cast: Anna Dempf as Connie, and Shae Fitzgerald as Cin.
Stage Manager: Kat Catalbo. Set Design and Construction: Michael A. Lake. Lighting Design: M Pomazal-Flanders. Light Board Operator: Pick Curran. Sound Design and Operation: Andrew Deitch. Props: Kat Fronheiser and Michael Kennedy, assisted by Seneca Kennedy, Shae Fitzgerald, and Dalina Quinones. Costumes: Shae Fitzgerald, Cameryn Coetzee, and Michael Kennedy.
Performance dates are Fridays and Saturdays, November 13-14 and 20-21. Friday and Saturday curtains are at 7:30 pm, and Saturday matinees are at 4:00 pm. Tickets are $20, with free tickets available for low-income audience members. Runs approximately 75 minutes without intermission. Tickets are available online. Visit https://creativeactionunlimited.com/current-season for more information.

