REVIEW: “The Fantasticks” at the Mac-Haydn Theatre

by Barbara Waldinger Premiering on May 3, 1960 at the compact Sullivan Street Playhouse in Greenwich Village, NYC, THE FANTASTICKS ran there for forty-two years:  the longest-running off-Broadway musical in American history.  How many Baby Boomers, including this reviewer, remember attending the play with its original cast (including Jerry Orbach…