(l to r) Cynthia Nixon (She) and Chris Lowell (He). Photo by T. Charles Erickson
Chris Lowell (He) and Penny Fuller (Mother). Photo by T. Charles Erickson.
Cynthia Nixon (She). Photo by T. Charles Erickson.
(l to r) Chris Lowell (He) and Cynthia Nixon (She). Photo by Paul Fox
(l to r) Penny Fuller (Mother) and Chris Lowell (He). Photo by T. Charles Erickson
Kinship by Carey Perloff and directed by Jo Bonney is about obsession
Theatre Review by Roseann Cane
Phèdre, Racine’s 17th-Century masterpiece, was a retelling of a Greek tragedy already examined many centuries before by Greek and Roman writers. What made this retelling so striking is the focus on the title character, previously portrayed as a monstrously evil woman. Racine’s Phèdre is a psychologically complex character whose obsession drives her to commit terrible acts, but this time she is more human than monster, and though she causes great suffering she is also a victim trapped in her own obsessions.
Playwright Carey Perloff was inspired to write Kinship in 2009, when she was directing Phèdre at the Stratford Festival in Ontario. “I was really trying to understand the nature of obsession,” she has said. “I love obsession, but it’s really strange. It’s not rational: it feeds on itself, so you need more, and more, and more of that drug to keep you feeling alive, even though you know it’s destructive. When it turns out that Hippolytus [Phèdre’s stepson] is in love with someone else, Phèdre becomes a monster, and decides she’s going…to take them down.”
In Kinship, the story is told through three characters, She (Cynthia Nixon), Friend/His Mother (Penny Fuller), and He (Chris Lowell). She is a driven, powerful middle-aged woman living a life many would envy. A successful newspaper editor, she has a devoted husband and two children she clearly adores. Her dear somewhat-older friend (Fuller) is at once motherly and sisterly toward her. While making a work transition into the digital realm, She hires He, a young reporter. Before long She falls for He, behaving like a smitten teenager, saving bits of paper he’s written on and glasses he’s drunk from. As her shoulder bag becomes ever more stuffed with His stuff, we see her careen into the throes of obsession. Her confidante, her dear friend, seeing the ever-expanding shoulder bag, cautiously cheers her on, and advises her without judgment. But eventually, inevitably, the friend learns the identity of the young reporter.
Perloff’s writing and the structure of her play, including numerous remarks all three actors make about a production of Phèdre they’ve attended, is (unlike Phèdre) a touch inelegant and ham-handed. Perhaps the play would had a more profound impact had the playwright done less telegraphing.
I had high hopes for this cast. Cynthia Nixon and Penny Fuller are gifted actors who’ve proven their chops over the decades. I’d not seen Chris Lowell on the stage before. He has a natural, easy charm.
Every time I enter a theater I hope, I want, to be surprised and delighted. It pains me to report that Kinship, this examination of obsession, was devoid of passion. I detected no chemistry between Nixon and Lowell. The language and gestures may have been there, but without any heat, it’s just words, words, words. I have the sense that Lowell could do so much more; I know Nixon can. Fuller is well cast but put at a disadvantage with no palpable electricity between her cast mates.
On the technical side, my kudos to all. Jo Bonney has directed with a sure hand, and Rachel Hauck’s angular, almost-bare bones set design fits the play beautifully. Sound designer Fitz Patton enhances the action, and Candice Donnelly’s costume design is just right.
Kinship by Carey Perloff, Directed by Jo Bonney; Scenic design, Rachel Hauck; Costumes, Candice Donnelly; Lighting, Philip Rosenberg; Sound, Fitz Patton; Director of production, Eric Nottke; Stage Manager, Jennifer Wheeler Kahn.
Cast: Cynthia Nixon (She), (Friend/ his mother) Penny Fuller, (He) Chris Lowell
Williamstown Theatre Festival’s Nikos Stage. Running time 100 minutes with no intermission. July 15 – 25, 2015 The run is sold out.
That’s a tough one Larry!
Larry I agree with this review.
There could have been more critical analysis of the performances and their issues.. BestCharles
Quite the ridiculous review. How can you say “no heat, no chemistry, no passion, just words, the actors (could have done) so much more” and then praise the directing job? Last night’s audience would certainly have disagreed with you, by the way.
Why Cynthia Nixon’s character becomes obsessed with Lowell is a great mystery to me and the main reason this production was such a disappointment. I went in with great expectations, a big fan of Ms. Nixon’s work. The premise seemed great and the flattering piece in the Boston Globe resulted in my splurging for a ticket.
I left disappointed but a bit uncertain why. As an actress Nixon created some brilliant moments. The premise is intriguing.
When Nixon and Lowell first meet (he bumps into her sending the papers she is carrying flying) there is nothing in that moment, the director and actor’s created, that supports all that is to follow. Nixon’s reaction is more that of a school girl, than the high powered over stressed editor set up in prior first scene. How much more interesting it would have been for her to behave as we would expect of many people in such a high powered position and then for something to catch her eye about Lowell.
The script and creative choices continue to fail in supporting what motivates Ms. Nixon to risk everything. She doesn’t seem bored in her marriage at home, dislike being mom and her career success is exploding as a new app released in the first scene does better than anyone could have imagined. References to her husband in no way suggest she is unhappy in the marriage or she is unfulfilled, emotionally, sexually etc. Are we supposed to read into the script, the fact that Nixon’s husband is an OB-GYN he is never home, never has sex with her, is emotionally unavailable?
Chris Lowell is an attractive man but again, there is nothing in the creative choices to suggest pure animal lust and attraction, either in his looks or his manner. Lowell’s character is something of a loser. He is almost 30. He has not really achieved much that is notable in life. His mother keeps harping that perhaps he will finally make something of himself on this job. When he is given the responsibility of writing a major piece he fails to deliver. Nixon comments he knows nothing about Journalism … I’ll have to rewrite it all myself. And when it’s finally time for him to “put out” in the bedroom he crumbles and runs off whining like a little boy that he didn’t get a ticket to hear Nixon give her keynote speech Why is she attracted to this guy?
And so Carey Perloff proves, yes people become obsessed, make stupid choices and risk losing everything. What remains unanswered for me is the question Perloff says first motivated her to pen the play, WHY? Why is she obsessed? Why is she risking it all?